Seattle Community

Greatly helpful
8.2
out of 10
10 votes

Why it Doesn't Always Suck to Work for Pennies

Working for less than your industry's going rate is a point of argument amongst freelancers, but under the right circumstances, working for cheap or free can benefit your career. Read on to find out how.
Written Oct 27, 2008, read 374 times since then.

 

As freelancers, our goal is to bring home the bacon - and lots of it.  Since we're responsible for paying 100% of our health benefits, business expenses, and retirement contributions, those of us in business for ourselves are keenly aware of where every dollar comes from and exactly where it goes.  As such, we need to charge a fair rate for our work and not undercut ourselves or underbid our colleagues.  We need to make ends meet, and odd are we don't have a huge chunk of change in the bank to fall back on in case the well dries up.

Occasionally, though, it behooves us to work for less than we're worth.  Maybe even - gasp - work for free!  In this big bad world of looming mortgage payments and high interest credit cards, why would a competent freelancer worth their salt consider accepting pennies on the dollar for their time and expertise?

Philanthropy, that's why.

Now before you roll your eyes and close your browser window, there are some very solid professional reasons why a reputable freelancer should consider providing cheap or pro-bono work for those that can't afford to pay their full rate:

* Exposure.  If your portfolio is lacking in some areas, performing work for non-profits and smaller businesses will provide you with much needed clips for industries you're trying to break into.

* Word gets around.  Honestly, networking and word of mouth are a freelancer's best friend.  Who knows who that small-time CEO, the one you produced a few brochures for on the cheap, has drinks with after work?  Or which high-tech bigwigs have their fingers in the charity you're helping out?  Not only will working for these smaller organizations increase your visibility, it will help you develop a solid reputation.  Who doesn't want to be known as a possessor of both talent and strong character?

* Variety.  If you're working for free or cheap, you're more likely to jump into projects you're less familiar with.  Say a small company needs a short script for their "Yes on Prop X" radio spot, something that you're moderately curious about but have no experience with.  If you're an hot shot freelance copywriter, your pro-bono client will be more than happy to have you do their work, regardless of your lack of radio clips.  Just be sure to do some digging for information on how to perform the task effectively - you still want to perform at your best.

* Karma points.  Regardless of if you believe it or not, paying a favor forward will always help you come out on top.  Even if it doesn't make you rich and famous, you'll feel pretty damn good about yourself.

One thing you want to keep in mind about working for less than your standard rate: you still want to maintain boundaries with your discount and pro-bono clients, just like you would your regular clientele.  Nothing will burn out your good will faster than a nonpaying customer who requests 428364827 revisions or calls you at all hours of the night wondering where their redesign is.  Just because they're getting you for cheap doesn't mean they shouldn't be held to the same contract as your paying gigs.  In fact, it's often a good idea to quote your regular rate in your contract and then clearly stipulate a discount for the work currently being performed.

Just because you're not getting your standard contract rate for a job doesn't necessarily mean you're selling yourself short.  If you make it a point to maintain solid boundaries between your regular clients and those that you're doing a favor for, there are a load of benefits to be had by working with a few select charity clients.  And who knows - that non-paying gig may turn into a gold mine down the road.

Learn more about the author, Stephanie Stiavetti.

Comment on this article

  • Bob Dunn
    Posted by Bob Dunn, Seattle and Renton, Washington | Oct 27, 2008

    Hey Stephanie, thanks for the article. These are really good points. When we started out of creative company 16 years ago, that's exactly what we did. Lot's of pro bono to organizations and nonprofits. Our name was everywhere, and it did help with our branding and getting the word out.

    A few other points I would like to add:

    I would be careful giving those deals to the "for profit" businesses, even if they are small and starting up. I have done it in the past and if I know the company or owner(s) well. But one problem that can result is they may continue to expect these kind of deals. And when is the right time to start asking for your full rate? I don't know how many times I have met with a new biz and they say "We are just starting out, so if you can help us now, we'll make it worth your while down the road". Most likely, not!

    Another great thing about doing pro bono for nonprofits, is they may give you more free "creative" reign. It gives you the chance to really show your stuff.

    And finally, when doing work for nonprofits it's best to find the one's whose work you have a passion for. It will make the project even more successful if what you are giving away is something you have a "heart" for.

    In addition, you are right about where it can lead. Between major donors and board members, who knows if they own a business that could use you help.

    Again, thanks for the post!

    ~bob

  • Thomas Willa
    Posted by Thomas Willa, Renton, Washington | Oct 27, 2008

    Stephanie You have made a very strong argument for reduced rates and even working for free. While I am in the process of relocated from Hawaii and starting up, again it is tough to give services up for free. I agree about the potential benefits being worth the efforts. Thanks for reminding me about documenting the reduction in terms of contracts. I think clients can overlook discounts while they are reaping the benefit.

    Bob I agree about people taking advantage of discount rates. I think as small business entrepreneurs that offerring a discount for repeat business is a good policy and one as a custormers we should understand, too. I sometimes give a discount for a client who gave me real (profitable) referrals or the third photo shoot, product or services.

    Where there's a will there is a way.. I am here to work not play.

    Thanks for keeping focused on what is real

  • Timothy Knuth
    Posted by Timothy Knuth, Bothell, Washington | Oct 27, 2008

    Having worked with many small businesses and non-profits, pricing is always a concern. Especially when both are start-ups, or similarly you know they are not bringing in much money.

    It is easy to feel for them and not want to charge one's normal rate. This I find especially true with non-profits.

    Here have been some guidelines that I try to follow. With non-profits I go into the situation knowing that I am going to give them a break. I usually give about 10 to 15%, depending on the type of work that they have going on at the time. I also express to them that this is my rate for non-profits. So incase they do want to recommend me to other places they are not telling the other people the rate that I am giving them. What I have found that works best is that I tell them my normal rate is X and I am offering my discounted rate of Y. I find that by doing this right away offers a couple of benefits. First, they know that I am offering a rate other than my normal rate and this takes away the negotiation portion of the rate. Second, they know what I normally charge, so if they want to recommend me elsewhere, they have an idea of a rate they can quote.

    For smaller companies or ones that I know fit into the start-up category I sometimes will offer a lower rate. I try to be careful on this because we all know how hard it is to raise rates later. Often times I am being called in when there is a substantial about of work to be completed and I know that after wards that it will slow down a bit. So I will make a deal with them stating that with the current project I will charge by the project rather than an hourly rate. In my mind and on paper I am really calculating the project at an hourly rate. But it is never presented this way. I give more vague numbers to them, but in reality I am still offering them a deal. So for an example instead of charging them 12 @ 95.00 an hour and leave them a bill for $1140.00 I will tell them that in my experience that these types of projects average between 12 and 15 hours, and I can do the work for $1000.00 which is just over a 10% discount. I also explain if that for some reason the project takes longer than expected that I will eat those additional hours. This makes them feel good because they have a set price for the work and know that I am not going to run the bill up. They a also know that they are getting a slightly reduced rate, but it is harder to pinpoint. So it is harder for them to say….”well last time you only charged 85 an hour...” Then moving forward I charge my normal rate. In this case it is a win-win. I have a new client and they are getting what they need at a reduced rate.

    In the long run, I look at both the non-profit and the small company/start-up company as a win for the industry. Meaning that I am not lowering prices so low as to hurt the industry as a whole. The would not want to do anything that makes that entire industry (as in my case Network Consultant’s) to have to worry about price gouging, etc. As mentioned in the original article, it is hard enough having to pay one’s taxes, insurance, retirement, and all the other items that keep a business running.

    Just my thoughts...

  • Stephanie Stiavetti
    Posted by Stephanie Stiavetti, Oakland, California | Oct 27, 2008

    Bob, those are all excellent points. I'm in the process of writing a second article along the same lines, and I will certainly take what you said into account. Thanks!!

  • Stephanie Stiavetti
    Posted by Stephanie Stiavetti, Oakland, California | Oct 27, 2008

    Thomas, re: being taken advantage of, there are always those that will push the envelope. For my business, I always make it a point to list in my contract not only the discount rate, but the exact stipulations of the discount. In other words, I say specifically for this one project, or for this time frame.

    Good point about using discounts as a thanks for being paid a favor. I've been known to trade discounts as well, though I tread lightly there.

  • Kimberly Dow
    Posted by Kimberly Dow, Frederick, Maryland | Oct 28, 2008

    Thanks for the article, Stephanie. I try to limit my number of pro bono jobs to 3-4 per year. This way, I can change which non-profits I decide to work with and I get better variety (and usually more creative freedom as well).

    In addition, I have started offering a non-profit discount to my design clients. So far, it has really paid off in both portfolio quality work and referrals for bigger (and ultimately better paying) jobs. As Timothy mentioned above, I did have to start outlining my normal fee along with my non profit discount fees, so clients 1) know they are getting a discounted rate and 2) know what my "real" rates are in case they refer anyone my way. So far, this has worked out great for me and my small start-up design firm.

    -kim dow

  • Stephanie Stiavetti
    Posted by Stephanie Stiavetti, Oakland, California | Oct 30, 2008

    Hi Kim

    That's excellent news, win-win for everyone. I write for non-profits as well, and I love it.

  • Whit Anderson
    Posted by Whit Anderson, Oakland, California | Oct 31, 2008

    This is a good article. As a graphic designer I am often approached to do free work. Sometimes it works for me, sometimes it doesn't. You just have to make sure you're being fair to yourself.

  • Cari Jones
    Posted by Cari Jones, Seattle, Washington | Nov 01, 2008

    Thanks for the article Stephanie. I agree about paying it forward; we have to give in order to receive.

    I'm sure I don't even have to put in the reminder about the hazards of doing free (or reduced rate) work for friends! When I was starting out, I learned my lesson the hard way when it came time for them to pay their bill. Your comment about putting the "discount" or "free" service in your contract is a vitally important detail. Thanks for the tip!

  • Melinda  Maxwell
    Posted by Melinda Maxwell, Newcastle, Washington | Nov 01, 2008

    I really agree with you. I do a lot of inservice work and volunteering because I believe in giving back. I don't expect anything and it comes back at strange places and times. I am thankful for the space to donate my time. It has been part of my business model for almost thirty years. You put it so well and I appreciate this article. It came at a good time for me and I love the part of holding up standards! Thank you!

  • Beth Barany
    Posted by Beth Barany, Oakland, California | 6 days ago

    Thanks Stephanie. I want to second the notion of putting everything in writing. I recently took on a "scholarship" client, had her write an essay to qualify and explained the discount clearly in the contract. This way she understands her discount and can communicate that clearly to others.

  • Stephanie Stiavetti
    Posted by Stephanie Stiavetti, Oakland, California | 6 days ago

    Hi Beth,

    Good call! It's so important to make sure your client understands what's going on 100%.

    Happy new year!