The bigger question is how celebrities try to cash in on other people's expertise just because of their celebrity. Many people spend years learning their craft only for a celebrity to plagiarize the idea and write a book or make a TV show, appear on Oprah, Ellen, Tyra or whichever and sell a million books. It's our fault really because we're all celebrity watchers and just let it happen.
The Kirstie Alley Weight Loss Plan???
While Kirstie was gaining the latest 85lbs, she was developing her weight loss plan. Hilarious, if you ask me. So I've just uploaded a video blog to discuss 'celebrities' developing plans without the required training or education. I'm a personal trainer with years of experience and a university degree in exercise science. I wouldn't presume to teach Kirstie how to act but I draw the line when she announces her own weight loss program.
Please visit my profile to view video or visit YouTube at following: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gGIfUlqr4o
20 Bizniks have posted replies
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 07, 2009
-
Posted by Barry Hurd, Seattle, Washington | May 07, 2009
On the other side of the fence, I'll throw out the devil's advocate statement:
If a personal trainer has never lost 100 pounds, what makes an education more worthwhile than actual experience?
I would share the opinion that anyone who massively changes their own lifestyle (in a variety of areas) has learned a tremendous amount about the endeavor they overcome.
Specifically in regards to weight loss, addictive and habitual mindsets are a very tricky area of development. As a trainer, I'm sure you are aware that many people "fall off the horse" from time to time and need to make a very conscious decision to learn some new techniques.
Now in Kristie's case, she may be a complete nut (LoL) and her weight problem could be entirely in her head. I do know several very successful healthy living/personal trainers who have successful 30+ person businesses, but they are constantly falling on and off the course do to daily workload and life events.
I would love to have a huge survey done of the WeightWatchers and JennyCraig executive teams to find out how out of shape they are.
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 07, 2009
Good point Barry! The only thing that's good with overweight people telling others about their success story is the psychological aspect of enthusing people to lose the weight. In that respect, it's a good thing.
The problem is, when you are 30+ pounds overweight, there are serious complications going on with the cardiovascular system, the lungs, the blood, the metabolism, the uptake in sugar, the digestions of foods, the endocrine system, ... the list goes on.
So let's say you take someone who has just 2 of those problems, we'll say, high blood pressure and high blood sugar levels, (which are severely common) and you throw them on a celeb "biggest loser" type plan... The stimulus would be too high, the body would start over stressing itself to the point where blood pressure is elevated to dangerous levels, same with heart rate etc., complications eg. heart attack, can easily be induced.
One of the things that my PhD college professors specialize and teach me in is training someone who has those issues. It is ESSENTIAL to the clients health you train them within certain cardiovascular parameters, or serious complications, including death, can occur.
There have been various lawsuits in multiple gyms and weight loss pills and drugs that have occurred for the very reason of having an uneducated person take a sick client and train them beyond what their body is ready, medically, to do.
This is why it's just idiotic for a celeb or uneducated "personal trainer" to help someone who has medical problems. It's a dangerous disaster waiting to happen.
-
Posted by Tammy Redmon, Seattle, Tacoma, Olympia, Washington | May 08, 2009
Whether it's Kirstie or Sally Jo down the street. Isn't part of the challenge that we are in a 'got to have it now' - drive thru mentality in most all aspects of life. Few people are talking about the benefits of taking time each day for exquisite self care - emotionally and physically.
Reality TV is a huge culprit in spreading lies vs. truth telling. It would be refreshing to begin to see the truth side of addiction for a change. Because isn't that really what Kirstie is dealing with? She replaced the drugs and alcohol with food. Not uncommon.
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 08, 2009
True Tammy!
Addictions and addictive behavior can come in many ways...
Did you know that the body, after years, months, or even days of abuse with sugar and starches can become addicted to the influx of sugar?
Have you ever felt that if you have just 1 bad pastry, or a small piece of cake, or a couple of cookies you want more? Sugar is a drug! The properties it has on the body is astounding. The damage it can do over the course of time is scary.
A lot of companies put addictive properties in foods, such as milk, to have consumers want more.
It's no surprise to me when I see people like Kirstie constantly "fall off the wagon" because she isn't strong enough to beat her addictions on her own. Her body is in a toxic state, and she's constantly wrestling that. She shouldn't have to.
Our bodies were made perfect. We put substances into our bodies that abuse it, and the results show from the way we look and feel.
-
Posted by Terry Murphy, Fareham, Hampshire United Kingdom | May 08, 2009
Tammy, I love this debate. As someone who has lost 140 lbs I resonate to 'careful and healthy' when it comes to losing weight. And also addiction....'scuse me just got to grab a chocolate bar, one can't hurt.
Bye the way, I also appreciate your 'no holds barred' writing "...it's just idiotic..." :)
Picking up on what Barry said, it is perhaps tricky for a wonderfully, slender, toned bodied personal trainer or dietitian to know what it really feels like to carry and lose a lot of weight. But not all heart surgeons have had open-heart surgery, and not not all psychologists are experienced psychopaths or rapists. I guess being well trained by good tutors (PhD's), being a good learner and then gaining experience is the way to make up for this.
--Terry
-
Posted by Christine Ely, Renton, Washington | May 08, 2009
Terry, Christin gets lots of feedback from me (and her other clients I'm sure)! I lost 60lbs working with her and complained all the way. I'll never put that weight back on again... but what it has taught me is to work with people who truly know their subject. A qualified fitness trainer gives me more confidence that a yo-yo dieting celeb.
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 08, 2009
"wonderfully, slender, toned bodied personal trainer" - Such praise haha =) Thanks!
Terry you hit on a good point. I don't know what it feels like, and Lord help me, I never will.
The good thing is that I'm at least an educated trainer that knows not to pile on the weights when I do have a severely overweight or obese client... or push them to dangerous levels enough to where they collapse on a treadmill (Jillian Michaels), as this is severely dangerous and "idiotic". I understand what the body is going through, and I give my recommendations and train people in accordance with those precautions.
There are strict guidelines I have learned about training people in that situation, and it went further in detail about the training parameters, internally, externally and emotionally to provide the safest, most effective health intervention possible.
I did however, do a 2 hour long workout with a 50lb weight vest and did hill runs. It sucked. It was difficult!
I'm pretty much that type of trainer that admits, yes, I've not been severely overweight before, I understand that, but facts are facts. Parameters are parameters. Most physiological things don't and wouldn't change, even if I did have the experience of being 100 lbs overweight. I'd still do what I am doing now:
- Pool workouts
- No weight training
- Body weight exercises only
- Heart Rate monitoring
- Weekly Blood pressure Readings
- Focus on Cardio: walking, biking, elliptical
- Focus on helping in the Lifestyle
- Encouraging and Supporting Clients
- Cleansing and detoxing the Body with Healthy Tart
- Helping them find and achieve a realistic and achievable goal.
-
Posted by Terry Murphy, Fareham, Hampshire United Kingdom | May 08, 2009
Christine and Christin, I hope you both read my input the right way. I am agreeing that although a specialist has not necessarily undergone what their charge is undergoing, it is not necessary in order to do a good job. Ridiculous for a celebrity (I thnk of Oprah rather than Kirstie), to "tell us how to do it", especially when they then immediately reverse course and get overweight again.
My comment was an endorsement of Christin's perspective.
--Terry
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 08, 2009
Yes siree! I did understand =)
Thank you for the wonderful compliment and congratulations on your weight loss success! Keep up the good work and I'm excited to meet you!
Christin
-
Posted by Terry Murphy, Fareham, Hampshire United Kingdom | May 09, 2009
(Perhaps I should now admit that my 140 lb loss was spread over 3 separate occasions, 35-50 lbs each time, with me gaining the weight back in the two periods in between. So I know, if I let it happen again, I will need 'professional' help, not just "doing it my way". Which is why I don't share with others how I did it....hehe)
-
Posted by Tammy Redmon, Seattle, Tacoma, Olympia, Washington | May 09, 2009
Ok So Christin, what about metabolism? Your workout routine above is great and I do 3/4 of it and my metabolism won't move. What tips can you offer - because the Doctors can't seem to help.
Not trying for free advice - I am just curious. I have heard a bunch of stories around the 'why' factor and have had my fair share of trainers totally stumped.
Do you do an analysis with folks who live out of your local area?
-
Posted by Terra Vita, Puget Sound, Washington | May 09, 2009
I look at all my once slender friends, we were the ones who ran or walked daily, early on adopted trainers, filled the yoga classes and hike the trails and byways.
A recent meeting of old compadres suggested that not one of us made it through menopause without at least thirty extra pounds.
It is insidious and sad. I exercise and have a weight loss trainer but am still for lack of a better word, fat. I now just want to be happy with where I am and be healthy.
-
Posted by Christine Ely, Renton, Washington | May 09, 2009
Terra, Come to our event on Friday: http://biznik.com/members/christin-mcdowell/events/you-dont-have-to-be-a-skinny-bitch-to-be-a-healthy-tart
I was 50lbs overweight, over 50 and thinking, "OK this is it... always be this weight". But it wasn't. Working with Christin and Healthy Tart book changed everything. We're giving a free copy of Healthy Tart to everyone that comes to event. I'll never go back to being overweight again!
-
Posted by Tammy Redmon, Seattle, Tacoma, Olympia, Washington | May 09, 2009
Terra, Feel the pain sister. And hear the peace and desire for some quality of joy around where you are today.
Amen!
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 09, 2009
Tammy and Terra ~
In the issue of metabolism, metabolism in the breakdown of calories will be the same for everyone. When you exercise, you burn calories, and the rate at which you burn them wont change unless you have a bunch of muscle mass, for which we women don't need to worry about.
SO- with metabolism, you've got to exercise if you want to burn fat and lose weight. (I'm not addressing the metabolism of food right yet). 95% of the trainers out there train their females WRONG. That is why I highly encourage you both to come to my event. You MUST exercise to burn calories- lots of them. So this doesn't mean weight training, riding on some stationary bike or even walking (unless you weigh 100lbs too much), this means running, swimming, sprinting- stuff that will burn SERIOUS calories. The good thing is that this form of training is the kind of training that will benefit your cardiovascular health the best... You don't want to start off right away with that form of training if you're just starting out, or if you have medical problems, but if should be your goal to get there.
I will talk more in detail during my presentation at the Healthy Tart event.
As far as your food metabolism, I haven't yet heard a woman out there who has a high metabolism. Our hormones were made to store fat, that's what we were "blessed" with... due to this God given natural phenomenon, we have got to evaluate the foods we are eating. If you think you eat well, but you're not losing weight, there's no catch. YOU'RE NOT eating as well as you think. We're not freaks of nature. Our metabolisms are all pretty much the same. We can alter them through exercise and how much of it we do, and we can alter it through drugs and shots, (which I don't endorse!).
I can be in denial as much as I want to of why I can't lose weight, but really what it comes down to is, how much and the quality of food I am eating. You must eat CLEAN food. This probably doesn't mean what you are thinking.
I want you to take a look at this woman.
http://ola-life.org/videos.php Look at her making Living Cacao Cream Pie, Nori Rolls, and Spring Rolls.
She eats 100% pure and organic food and she is vegan. She is the leanest natural person I've ever seen, and she's pregnant. OBVIOUSLY she's got it down. She's serving her body and her body is serving her. She inspires me to want to change and be even better. She eats like a Healthy Tart would.
So, even though you are thinking you are eating the right stuff, you're not if you're not at your optimal weight. Something is wrong. Something you are DOING is wrong.
We can explore this further together in the Healthy Tart event.
Yes, your metabolism slightly slows down in your 40's and 50's.. WHY? Because you become LESS ACTIVE and you start losing muscle mass because you are LESS ACTIVE. Chris is a testament to that. She easily lost 60lbs and she's over 50. It's not rocket science people, it's really quite simple.
I implore you to come to our event to learn more about what you can do to change your body and the way you think and feel!
-
Posted by Christine Ely, Renton, Washington | May 11, 2009
Event is on Friday: If you struggle with weight loss and maintaining your optimum weight, then you should really visit this event... and you get a free copy of Healthy Tart!
-
Posted by Christin McDowell, Renton, Washington | May 12, 2009
Looking forward to my weight loss event on Friday. Uploaded video to my profile page with full details. Free copy of Healthy Tart for anyone who attends.
-
Posted by Christine Ely, Renton, Washington | May 15, 2009
Healthy Tart Weight Loss Program at Mosiac today. 11:30! Free Healthy Tart Book for everyone than comes! See you there Healthy Bizniks!!!
-
Posted by Kate Phillips, Carnation, Seattle, Washington | May 16, 2009
Great discussion. And I also think it's ridiculous to take fitness advice from chubby celebrities! (Makes so much more sense for the experts to become celebrities, don't you think!?)
Christin, I'm curious if you're familiar with Jon Gabriel's book/work and concept of how much our mind can influence our weight and turn our "fat programs" on or off. Particularly how, if we associate weight with "safety" for some reason, our bodies will "want" to gain weight. I'm seeing some very interesting correlations with weight gain/weight loss in my own life.
This forum is unmoderated, but please keep discussion courteous and not too far off topic.
Members posting in this topic
Post tags
- weight loss
- nutrition
- kirstie alley
- plan
- jenny craig
- oprah
- body fat
- exercise
- fitness
- healthy tart

