Kristy,
Like Josh, above, I agree with some of what you have said here and have a different point of view on some of it as well.
Steven Covey asks us to begin with the end in mind. Or in other words, to have a plan for what we want to achieve.
Networking, as you said, is about building relationships. Some people, however, treat networking as if it is a "trolling for client" event and it is those people who make events unbearable or as you put it "sucky or ech".
So there are two truths at work when you look at the "begin with the end in mind" process.
First, networking is about building relationships. Second, if you are in business - all marketing (and networking is part of your marketing strategy) is about growing our business (also known as acquiring more clients)
It is the speed at which some folks desire the end result that puts the quandry into networking.
At eWomenNetwork, we focus on building relationships and we have a consistent process in place for people to introduce themselves to each other. We coach from the front of the room that the focus at each event is on being curious about others and what they say they do and what they need to grow their business.
We also teach people listening skills and connecting skills. Mostly we focus on building relationships. To that end we discourage the exchange of business cards, suggesting instead that people only exchange cards with people that they have specific information that they want to share or receive from that person.
Does everyone follow these guidelines? Not always, but the majority do. Those that don't and are predatory ... well they end up feeling pretty lonely and unconnected and they eventually go away (usually, they say .. Networking does not work for me)
With all that said, I'm going to disagree with Josh on the process of talking only with people that you need to know. I would not validate the notion of bypassing people that you do not need to know. For how do you truly know this?
I'm all about having a plan but the plan is more about what is it that you are hoping to attract? If you have a firm idea of what kind of clients you love to serve and you can help others to understand that perfect client ... then that person that you thought you did not need to know and bypassed might just be the person who knows 2 or 3 people that would be a potential client for you.
So, in full circle, it comes back to building relationships.
As a networker, you have the right to establish how you will engage with people that you talk with.
If you set your intention to meet 3 interesting people that you could begin the process of building relationships with ... then set out knowing that you will attract those folks to you and you do that by being curious and interested in others.
If you stumble upon folks who are not vibrating at that same level of curiousity, interest, and relationship, you can use your kindness by crafting a disengagement statement that helps you to quickly move away from aggressive or pushy networkers.
Wow, I know this is long ... and I hope it helps those who take the time to read it.

